Well I’d just say that if you want to be a writer who connects with a broad audience, it might help to do a little intro instead of just assuming everyone knows what you’re talking about. What is NanoWrimo? I had no idea when I began to read this and only a vague idea when I finished. But the conclusion does make sense: writing a bunch of words down does not equal communication. Ever go to a library and pick out random books, just for fun? There are thousands and thousands that are just not worth the time to read. Don’t count your words, make your words count.
You're quite right, I had hoped the third paragraph would offer enough clarity but upon reading it back, perhaps not. I'll see if we can sneak in a bit of an explainer at the start.
"NanoWrimo is an online activity that pushed writers toward set wordcount goals, and created a sense of community" would probably suffice
It's hard to see it now, at this end of the arc of history, but there was actually a time when NaNoWriMo was good. It was the late 2000s and early 2010s; when white males still believed they'd be allowed to join the great fraternity of "men of letters," and when some of us still thought if we could write a great novel, there would be people out there who were interested in reading it. NaNoWriMo was an introduction for many dreamers, to what the hard work of writing a novel would really be like; and for some that succeeded, it provided the self-belief that they were in fact capable of it.
We didn't know, at that time, what the arts were becoming, and what the publishing industry was turning into; and so at that time NaNoWriMo brought a number of naive believers together to try their best to create original work, based on original ideas. Unfortunately, I was present for most aspects of the fall of this structure. It is indeed true that in the last years, you would meet almost nothing but fanfiction and erotica writers; you would meet people who believed the very idea of pushing oneself to exceed what you thought you were capable of, was not sufficiently considerate of neurodivergents, different ways of thinking and knowing, etc. It's terrible now, but at one time, NaNoWriMo did represent something we didn't have elsewhere, and which might be impossible to build again in the world as it became.
I think it could be done again. I am the odd one out in my writing groups for not taking part in it. It certainly got a lot of people back into writing, and it will be a shame if nothing replaces the void that it will one day leave behind.
But the concept is simple. So anyone can grab at it and recreate it at home
Well I’d just say that if you want to be a writer who connects with a broad audience, it might help to do a little intro instead of just assuming everyone knows what you’re talking about. What is NanoWrimo? I had no idea when I began to read this and only a vague idea when I finished. But the conclusion does make sense: writing a bunch of words down does not equal communication. Ever go to a library and pick out random books, just for fun? There are thousands and thousands that are just not worth the time to read. Don’t count your words, make your words count.
You're quite right, I had hoped the third paragraph would offer enough clarity but upon reading it back, perhaps not. I'll see if we can sneak in a bit of an explainer at the start.
"NanoWrimo is an online activity that pushed writers toward set wordcount goals, and created a sense of community" would probably suffice
It's hard to see it now, at this end of the arc of history, but there was actually a time when NaNoWriMo was good. It was the late 2000s and early 2010s; when white males still believed they'd be allowed to join the great fraternity of "men of letters," and when some of us still thought if we could write a great novel, there would be people out there who were interested in reading it. NaNoWriMo was an introduction for many dreamers, to what the hard work of writing a novel would really be like; and for some that succeeded, it provided the self-belief that they were in fact capable of it.
We didn't know, at that time, what the arts were becoming, and what the publishing industry was turning into; and so at that time NaNoWriMo brought a number of naive believers together to try their best to create original work, based on original ideas. Unfortunately, I was present for most aspects of the fall of this structure. It is indeed true that in the last years, you would meet almost nothing but fanfiction and erotica writers; you would meet people who believed the very idea of pushing oneself to exceed what you thought you were capable of, was not sufficiently considerate of neurodivergents, different ways of thinking and knowing, etc. It's terrible now, but at one time, NaNoWriMo did represent something we didn't have elsewhere, and which might be impossible to build again in the world as it became.
I think it could be done again. I am the odd one out in my writing groups for not taking part in it. It certainly got a lot of people back into writing, and it will be a shame if nothing replaces the void that it will one day leave behind.
But the concept is simple. So anyone can grab at it and recreate it at home