Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steven's avatar

Someone once said "An expert outside his area of expertise is just another layman."

I wish celebrities would remember this fact. I am no more interested in their opinion on politics, economics, trade, foreign policy, etc than I am in their opinions on quantum mechanics, string theory, or astrophysics; they are are equally unqualified to comment on any of the topics above.

I realize that the lines have become increasingly blurred as one party runs a former reality TV star and the other runs candidates who can't speak intelligibly without a teleprompter, but a mere proficiency in reciting lines or lyrics does nothing to recommend someone as a public servant.

Moreover, I agree with another sentiment I've heard attempting to characterize celebrity endorsements: they are, at best, an attempt to invoke the Halo Fallacy by associating a candidate with someone more popular, and at worst, they are a form of voter intimidation, implicitly threatening dissenting voters with social censure from their legions of fans.

If celebrities want to use their Freedom of Speech to mention who they plan on voting for, whatever, but they really shouldn't be endorsing or stumping for candidates as if they had any political expertise or relevance. They're outside their lane. Elections in general should NOT be a popularity contest, they should be decided on policies and competence, like any other hiring of a government employee.

Expand full comment
BeadleBlog's avatar

All of us get to have our opinions, including those in the entertainment industry. Being a celebrity (or in any other profession) doesn't, imo, automatically disqualify or support one's opinions and intelligence. But I have a qualifier, and that support has to be explained or it's meaningless and it's ignored. Love "The circus parade of celebrities, wide-eyed, perfect-haired, and smiling feels emptier than ever before." YES! The level of plasticity that comes out of most Hollywood films and TV has turned me off and driven me to look more and more at foreign films, where women wake up with messy hair and the adults are doing other things besides shooting, crashing cars and constantly humping. If I wanted to stare at vacuous, plastic mannequins that don't think, I would go to a department store clothing section and take a walk.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts